Bio-ethanol fireplace or water vapour fireplace?
Bio-ethanol fireplace or water vapour fireplace: which suits you?
Both are decorative fireplaces that need no chimney, but they work in very different ways. A bio-ethanol fireplace gives you a real flame fuelled by liquid fuel. A water vapour fireplace, Safretti’s Magic-Fire, creates a realistic, cool flame from illuminated water vapour and runs on electricity and water. If you want the experience of a real fire, go for bio-ethanol. If you want realism without real fire, at much lower running costs and with maximum safety, go for water vapour.
The main difference: a real flame or a realistic vapour flame
With a bio-ethanol fireplace you see a real, living flame that burns bio-ethanol. That gives you the authentic experience of fire, along with all the care that comes with it.
With a water vapour fireplace, the flame is actually illuminated water vapour. A vaporiser produces a fine, cool mist and LED lighting turns it into a three-dimensional flame effect that looks surprisingly real and that you can even touch. There is no fire, no smoke and no heat.
Running costs
This is where the difference is biggest. A bio-ethanol fireplace runs on fuel and costs roughly €0.65 to €1.65 per hour. A water vapour fireplace runs on electricity and water and costs just €0.03 to €0.08 per hour. If you like to enjoy the atmosphere often, a water vapour fireplace is far cheaper to run, and you never have to buy fuel.
Safety
A bio-ethanol fireplace is safe when used correctly, but it is still an open flame with highly flammable fuel. Safretti fireplaces are TÜV-certified and have an adjustable burner that can be closed off.
A water vapour fireplace is safer still, because there is no real fire. The flame is cool and safe to touch, the models are CE-certified and safe around children and pets, and they alert you when the water is running low. For families with children or pets, water vapour is the most worry-free choice.
Maintenance and convenience
Both need some attention, just in different ways. With a bio-ethanol fireplace you buy fuel, refill it once the fireplace has cooled down and clean the fuel box every now and then. With a water vapour fireplace you top up the water or connect it to the mains water supply, and clean the reservoir and filters once every two weeks, especially if you have hard water.
Ventilation and placement
Neither needs a chimney or flue, so you can place them freely in the room. The difference lies in ventilation: a bio-ethanol fireplace uses oxygen and therefore needs a good supply of fresh air, while a water vapour fireplace involves no combustion and actually raises the humidity slightly.
Side-by-side comparison
| Bio-ethanol fireplace | Water vapour fireplace (Magic-Fire) | |
|---|---|---|
| Flame | Real flame | Realistic 3D flame from water vapour, cool |
| Runs on | Bio-ethanol (fuel) | Electricity and water |
| Chimney | Not needed | Not needed |
| Ventilation | Needed | Not needed |
| Running costs | Approx. €0.65 to €1.65 per hour | Approx. €0.03 to €0.08 per hour |
| Heat | Limited, for atmosphere | None, for atmosphere |
| Maintenance | Refill fuel, clean burner | Top up water, clean reservoir and filters |
| Safety | Open flame, care needed | Cool flame, very safe |
| Certification | TÜV | CE |
Which fireplace should you choose?
- Do you want the experience of a real flame? Choose a bio-ethanol fireplace.
- Do you want realism without real fire, the lowest costs and the highest level of safety? Choose a water vapour fireplace.
- Still unsure? Both create atmosphere without a chimney, so the deciding factor is mainly whether you really want a real flame.
Safretti decorative fireplaces
Safretti manufactures both types of decorative fireplace, with no building work involved. You can choose from bio-ethanol fireplaces with a real flame, and water vapour fireplaces from the Magic-Fire collection with a realistic, cool flame. We provide our own advice, installation and service to help you make the right choice.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a bio-ethanol fireplace and a water vapour fireplace? A bio-ethanol fireplace has a real flame fuelled by liquid fuel, while a water vapour fireplace creates a realistic, cool flame from illuminated water vapour and runs on electricity and water.
Which is cheaper to run? The water vapour fireplace, at €0.03 to €0.08 per hour compared with €0.65 to €1.65 per hour for bio-ethanol.
Which is safer? The water vapour fireplace, because there is no real fire. The flame is cool and safe to touch.
Which one has a real flame? The bio-ethanol fireplace. A water vapour fireplace looks realistic, but it is not real fire.
Does either of them need a chimney? No. Neither fireplace needs a chimney or flue.
A real flame or realism without fire
Bio-ethanol and water vapour both create atmosphere without a chimney, but in different ways. A bio-ethanol fireplace gives you the experience of a real flame, while a water vapour fireplace offers realism without fire, at minimal cost and with maximum safety. Take a look at Safretti’s bio-ethanol fireplaces or water vapour fireplaces, or ask us for personal advice on the fireplace that suits you.